Last Updated on September 16, 2022
There are two theories on when Snape called Lily a mudblood. One is that the incident took place before ‚Snape‚s Worst Memory‚ was written, and the other is that Lily opened her mouth, but didn‚t speak. Regardless of which theory is correct, Lily‚s feelings for Severus were platonic throughout their friendship.
‚Willow Incident‚ took place before ‚Snape‚s Worst Memory‚
The ‚Willow Incident‚ took shape before ‚Snape‚s worst memory‚ was published in 1999. It took place during the fifth year of Hogwarts, before the first other classes began. In his OWL for Defense Against the Dark Arts, Sirius and James humiliated him. Lily intervened and stopped them. Severus called her ‚Mudblood‚. He apologized to her in front of Gryffindor House, but she refused to have a friendship with him.
Sirius tells Snape how to get through the Whomping Willow, and the two of them end up in a tunnel. James and Sirius will soon return to their houses, and they will be together for several days. In fact, James and Sirius will be moving into 12 Grimmauld Place shortly. As they discuss this, Snape realizes that he has a werewolf on his hands, and he is very suspicious of his new family.
The ‚Willow Incident‚ took places before ‚Snape‚s worst memory‚. In fact, if the ‚Willow Incident‚ took place before ‚Snape‚s Worst Memory‚, it would have taken place before the OWLs, and Sirius would have been 22 at the time.
Snape called lily a mudblood
The question “When did Snape call Lily a mudblood?” has often been a source of controversy. While Lily was an innocent muggle born, many people believe that her real identity is Muggle. This theory is not backed up by any evidence, but merely speculates. The muggle-born Lily Evans would have been a perfect match for a pure-blood wizard like Snape, and would have probably tried to make Snape his friend before coming to Hogwarts.
The answer to the question “When did Snape call Lily a mudblood?” is very simple: he called her that during the heat of the moment. In another situation, Snape would have called her a bitch, or a generic insult, but it was a specific slur against her heritage. Moreover, it was a slip of the tongue.
After the incident, Snape apologized for his mistake repeatedly, but his lies to Lily continued. He had a long history of lying to Lily, and had used the m*dbl**d word around him for a while. While he was not calling Lily a mudblood yet, he had already used it around other Muggle Borns in school and was influenced by James Potter. It is easy to see that Snape lost control and called Lily a mudblood before he had the chance to think about it.
lily opened her mouth but did not speak
In the Harry Potter books, Snape often calls Lily a mudblood, a racial slur for witches. While Lily calls him out, he essentially tunes her out when she says that she‚s not a mudblood, and that it‚s no problem for him to call her that.
It was one of the first times Lily had seen Snape. She had seen him in his class, and he had gotten to know him. They‚d shared conversations and made out a few times before, and he was intrigued by her bright eyes and hair. Lily had coerced him into doing things like helping her with her chores and lying on her stomach in her room. She knew he liked to listen to records and make recordings. Once, she stood frozen in the doorway, but had not spoken.
Lily held Severus‚ hand and gently tugged on it, but she did not say a word. They climbed up the attic stairs and into a room covered in Cloaking spells. Severus and Lily walked into a room that was cluttered with crates and other objects. Lily opened her mouth but did not speak when snape called her a mudblood
lily‚s feelings for Severus remained platonic throughout their friendship
Though Snape and Lily had become good friends, their relationship was always platonic. Throughout their friendship, Lily did not romanticize Snape‚s feelings for her. Lily merely saw Snape as a friend who was interested in her. The book, “Snape‚s Worst Memory”, contains Lily‚s response to Levicorpus.
Even though Lily didn‚t recognize Snape‚s feelings for her, he was deeply devoted to her. He hid his good heart behind his imposing demeanor. Their love for each other was initially pure, but later became obsessive and possessive. Nevertheless, the two never stopped being friends, and their affection for one another was evident in their Patronus.
Despite the discord between Lily and Petunia, Lily never made fun of Severus. She listened to his stories, eagerly. Their friendship did not end with Lily‚s fling with Snape, as Lily was still not sure if she wanted to be friends with him. Although she was attracted to Severus, her feelings for him remained platonic throughout their friendship.
lily‚s marriage to James Quora
The question of when did Snape call Lily a Mudblood is a complex one. It seems like he may have been in the heat of the moment and called her a “mudblood” to save her pride. However, the truth is that Snape and Lily were friends before they were confronted. Whether this was a slip of the tongue or the result of a jealousy based out of pride is unknown, but the answer is probably yes.
Although it was a controversial decision, Lily did become more likable once James Potter started bugging her. It would also be interesting if Snape called Lily a mudblood because he thought she was a Death Eater. That would certainly ruin the dynamic of the relationship between the two of them. But, in the end, Lily did not become a Mudblood; instead, she became a better person and man.
Snape‚s choice to be a bully
While it is hard to deny Snape‚s selfish motivations, his actions were not justified in the end. He loved Lily and wanted to protect her from Voldemort, who would surely spare her. Snape‚s decision to bully Lily was not only cruel, but also uncharacteristic. The muggles who witnessed the event were shocked and disgusted, but Snape‚s actions remained a mystery.
In Harry Potter, we see how Snape dealt with his own anger issues in a different way than many other people. While Snape may have had a tough childhood, he was still an extremely angry person who took out his anger and frustration on the people who depended on him. One of his worst moments was calling Lily Evans a mudblood. Even though Snape had long since moved on, his actions remained disturbing and dangerous.
This decision to be a bully came from his past experiences as a child. While he was in school, Snape had been hanging around with death eaters and dabbling in dark arts. His friendships with his friends were not healthy. He was also undergoing a personal crisis as he hid his dark secrets. The end of his school career had changed his life and his friendships were strained. Fortunately, Snape eventually met people who were more sympathetic to him. Despite his past struggles, he still had some people who remained loyal to him. But this did not change his stance towards Lady Muddleblood.
Snape was a Death Eater
In the Harry Potter series, Severus Snape met Lily Evans when he was nine. Almost immediately, he fell in love with her and the two became friends. They were both Sorted into Slytherin House, the same year that Lily was born, but in opposing houses. Despite their closeness, Snape never admitted his feelings for her, but they were friends.
Harry Snape was under a lot of pressure to prove himself and was often subject to mockery and humiliation. He feared the shame of not being able to save his friends from the Death Eaters, so he made up the word in a moment of frustration. He also called other Muggle Borns the same word, so it was no wonder he erred by calling Lily a mudblood.
While in the Death Eater ranks, Snape‚s relationship with Lily became strained. He had an unhappy home life and was embarrassed by his parents. At school, he was subject to relentless bullying and eventually lost the love of his life when he started dating the school bully James. Lily later returned to Snape and later apologized to him for calling her a “mudblood” when he was a Death Eater.
petunia
We know that Harry Potter was a mudblood, but when did Snape call Petunia a mudblood? It‚s difficult to say for sure, but I‚d imagine he called her that way for several reasons. It was probably because she was young and she was afraid of Severus. It is also possible that Petunia was scared of magic, and struck back because she was temporarily scared by Severus. Or maybe she simply didn‚t understand the tone of Snape‚s voice. Whatever the case, she did obey him, and this is the most infamous example.
Petunia has a sour relationship with her parents. She was a witch, and her parents were proud of her. However, Lily‚s parents chose Lily over her older sister, and both women remained close. It‚s also possible that Lily‚s parents still love Petunia, which may explain why Lily would have preferred her over Petunia.
About The Author
Gauthier Daniau is a freelance problem solver. He first discovered his knack for trouble-shooting when he was still in diapers - and hasn't looked back since. When he's not slaying zombies or internet ninjas, GAUTHIER enjoys working with animals of all shapes and sizes. He's also something of a social media expert and loves to get lost in numbers and figures.